I avoided Sherlock Holmes at the cinema. Partly because there were films I wanted to see more that were showing at the same time, but mostly because it looked a bit too much like a Wild Wild West/Shanghai Knights style telling of a Holmes story and I’m really not a fan of either of those. Presented with the opportunity to review the DVD however, I thought I’d give it a chance.
The movie has a strong footing to start from. It’s directed by Guy Ritchie, stars an interesting pairing of Robert Downey Jr and Jude Law as Holmes and Watson, has the rather sinister-looking Mark Strong as the main villain, and drops the lovely Rachel McAdams in as Holmes’ female associate and master criminal.
Holmes starts on a high by incarcerating the infamous black magician, Lord Blackwood, keeping London safe once more. He descends into a dull and unsatisfying existence with no cases to solve until it appears that Blackwood has risen from the grave to complete his true plan. The hunt starts once more for Holmes and this time he has to contend with a loved-up Watson, whose fiancée he rubs up the wrong way, and his own former love, Irene Adler
Throw away any ideas that Sherlock is a tweed-wearing, pipe-smoking, upper-class, clue-pondering toff. Instead consider that he is tweed-wearing, pipe-smoking, thrill-seeking, bare-knuckle boxing, incredibly observant genius, who appears to both love and hate the fact he knows everything. The idea of which I detested at first thought but having seen Holmes in action I’ve certainly become a fan of his style.
The scenes in which the audience is treated to a moment of Holmes clarity, when his senses allow him to see exactly what he needs to do in a given situation is pure brilliance. Holmes plans every one of his next moves knowing the consequences of each action before he acts and then treats us to a flurry of orchestrated movement resulting in exactly what he intended as an outcome. They are fantastic scenes and credit to Guy Ritchie for using them as a way of depicting Holmes’ observation skills.
Robert Downey Jr is his usual, charismatic, very cool self and he injects his style into the Holmes character, giving the world famous detective an edge that he shouldn’t have in the traditional sense but he does and it works. As much as I loved watching Downey Jr as Holmes, I had a real issue with the Holmes dialogue. The speech was very fast and very English, too English, I just couldn’t understand a thing he said half the time.
It’s a unique view on the Sherlock Holmes stories and not at all like my original fears of another Wild Wild West. It is full of olde English action and mystery, and gives us the starting point for what could well be a franchise. It is one of those films that you can just play, sit back and enjoy. There’s no need to over-exert your thinking muscles and equally you won’t get bored. It has some fantastic visuals and in parts is actually pretty funny. Sherlock Holmes gets 3 bowler hats out of 5.





